What Works On Reddit (Feedback from 100+ Users)
Get a full market clarity report so you can build a winning digital business
We research digital businesses every day, if you're building in this space, get our market clarity reports
Reddit is one of the hardest platforms to crack for driving traffic, but when you get it right, the results can be massive.
We spent weeks digging through forums, communities, and firsthand accounts from entrepreneurs who've built real businesses using Reddit. We compiled the patterns that actually work and filtered out everything that doesn't. What you'll find below are tested tactics from people who've generated tens of thousands of visitors, closed paying clients, and built sustainable traffic channels through Reddit, not theories from someone who's never done it.
These aren't generic "be helpful" tips, they're specific, actionable tactics with real numbers attached. If you're serious about understanding your market before you even start posting, our market clarity reports show you exactly what your audience complains about, where they hang out, and what messaging actually resonates with them.
Quick Summary
Reddit growth works when you stop treating it like a promotional channel and start treating it like a community you actually belong to.
The tactics that consistently deliver results involve strategic timing (posting 5-6 hours before peak activity), smart targeting (500-5K member subreddits), automated monitoring (F5Bot alerts within minutes), and trust building (150-500 karma before any promotion). The founders generating 47,000 visitors in 24 hours or closing $1,500 MRR in their first month all followed specific, quantifiable approaches rather than vague advice.
What separates banned accounts from successful ones is usually one thing: they built karma and trust first, then promoted second.
In our market clarity reports, for each product and market, we detect signals from across the web and forums, identify pain points, and measure their frequency and intensity so you can be sure you're building something your market truly needs.
Proven tactics that separate successful Reddit growth from instant bans
1. You must use URL parameters to hide promotional elements strategically
What it is
You create a URL parameter like
?ref=redditor?ref=internetisbeautifulthat triggers your site to completely hide pricing pages, upgrade CTAs, and paid plan features when traffic arrives from Reddit. This removes the immediate sales feel that gets posts banned in restrictive subreddits while still capturing visitors. Marc Lou generated 47,000 visitors in 24 hours using this approach, and the Chatbase founder used it to create top 10 most upvoted posts of the year on r/saas, reaching 500,000 users.Why it works
Moderators check links before approving posts, and if they see a pricing page or obvious commercial intent, your post gets removed instantly. By hiding these elements specifically for Reddit traffic, you pass moderation while still showcasing your product's value. Once the post goes viral (before the eventual ban that usually follows), you can reactivate pricing to capture sales. The key insight is that moderators care about the initial impression, not what happens after users are already on your site.
How to execute it well
Add conditional logic in your frontend code that detects the ref parameter. When
ref=redditis detected, replace your pricing page with either an email collection form with a free lead magnet, or hide the pricing section entirely and show only free features. Use different parameters for different subreddits to track performance (?ref=entrepreneur,?ref=saas). Test the parameterized URL yourself before posting to ensure pricing is completely hidden. Consider that your post will likely get banned after going viral, but you'll capture significant traffic first.Sources: Marc Lou Newsletter, Indie Hackers2. You must set up F5Bot to monitor keywords and respond within minutes
What it is
F5Bot is a free monitoring service that emails you immediately when specific keywords related to problems your product solves appear on Reddit, Hacker News, or Lobsters. You set alerts for pain points and solution-seeking phrases (not just your product name), then respond to relevant discussions within minutes, before threads get buried. Multiple indie hackers credit F5Bot as their primary traffic source, with the ShipFast founder calling it their major success tool.
Why it works
Reddit moves quickly, and the first 5-10 responses to a question capture the most visibility and upvotes. Manually checking target subreddits means you'll miss 90% of relevant conversations. F5Bot acts as your automated scout, notifying you within minutes of opportunities to contribute value. This speed advantage lets you be among the first responders, significantly increasing your comment's visibility and the likelihood that the original poster engages with you directly.
How to execute it well
Visit f5bot.com and create a free account. Add 5-10 keywords focused on problems (like "scheduling tool," "need help with calendar," "automate social posts") rather than product names. Include competitor names if relevant. Set up email forwarding rules to ensure instant notifications reach you. When notified, read the full thread context before responding. Provide genuine value in your comment before any product mention, answer their specific question thoroughly, then add: "Full disclosure: I built [product] which handles this." Don't set up too many keywords (over 20) or you'll get notification fatigue. Respond within the first hour if possible, threads that are 6+ hours old have significantly less visibility.
3. You must use Reddit DM outreach with 40-45% response rates
What it is
You use keyword targeting to find Reddit users actively asking about problems your product solves, then send direct messages (not comments) with value-first messages. You ask about their problems first to determine relevancy before any product mention. Reddit allows up to 600 DMs per day. Nikola from Howitzer messaged 1,727 targeted users and generated $1,500 MRR in the first month, with 29.3% conversion from free to paid users.
Why it works
DMs feel personal and create one-on-one conversation rather than public performance. When someone posts asking for recommendations, they're in high-intent buying mode. DMs bypass the noise of public threads where dozens compete for attention. By asking qualifying questions first ("What specific features are most important to you?"), you demonstrate genuine interest rather than spray-and-pray sales tactics. This approach consistently generates 40-45% response rates, which is 10x better than cold email.
How to execute it well
Use F5Bot or manual search to identify users posting questions about your product category. Don't DM immediately. First, read their post history to understand their context and verify they're genuinely looking for solutions (not competitors researching). Send a first message without any links: "I saw your post about [problem]. I've worked with this issue extensively. Are you looking for [specific solution type A] or [solution type B]?" Wait for their response. Ask 2-3 qualifying questions to determine fit. Only after they've engaged positively do you mention: "Based on what you've described, you might want to check out [product]. I'm the founder, happy to answer questions." Never send product links in the first message, this gets flagged as spam. Limit DM outreach to 2-3 messages per Redditor per month.
Sources: Indie Hackers, Indie Hackers4. You must focus on first-hour upvote velocity above all else
What it is
Content receiving rapid upvotes within the first 60 minutes has exponentially higher chances of reaching Reddit's "hot" page and staying visible. A post getting 10 upvotes in the first hour will typically outrank content receiving 50 upvotes over 24 hours due to time-decay algorithms. Brands that actively participate in comment discussions receive 2.3x more upvotes than those who simply post content and disappear.
Why it works
Reddit's ranking algorithm uses time-decay weighting where early upvotes carry exponentially more weight than later ones. The first 30-60 minutes determine whether your content enters the "hot" feed algorithm. Once a post starts declining in the algorithm (typically after 4-6 hours without engagement), it's nearly impossible to resurrect. Early velocity creates momentum, more visibility leads to more upvotes, creating a virtuous cycle. Posts that fail to gain traction in the first hour rarely recover.
How to execute it well
Post during your target subreddit's moderately active hours (not dead silent, not peak saturation). Immediately after posting, engage in the comments yourself, post a thoughtful first comment adding context or asking a question to seed discussion. If you have a small community (email list, Discord, Slack), notify them immediately so genuine supporters can provide early upvotes (don't ask explicitly for upvotes, this violates Reddit rules). Use Reddit's crosspost feature to share to 2-3 related subreddits within the first 30 minutes. Monitor your post every 15 minutes for the first hour to respond to questions and keep discussion active. Don't manipulate votes through vote brigading or fake accounts, Reddit's systems detect this and will shadowban your content permanently.
Sources: Single Grain, Single Grain5. You should target subreddits with exactly 500-5,000 members for maximum ROI
What it is
Stop competing in massive subreddits and instead systematically identify and dominate small communities with 500-5,000 members where your expertise stands out. These sweet spot communities have enough regular activity that posts appear every few days, but not so much that your expert contributions drown in dozens of competing responses. Kamel Ben Yacoub closed 2 clients in 6 months using this approach, plus secured speaking invitations at major industry events.
Why it works
In subreddits with millions of members, questions get buried within hours and top experts monopolize visibility. In tiny subreddits (under 500), engagement is too sparse for consistent results. The 500-5K range provides regular engagement with minimal competition, questions often go unanswered for days, making you the obvious go-to expert. Members are highly engaged but starved for quality responses. For example, r/LinkedInAds has only 600 members but regular engagement, while r/marketing's millions of members create too much noise.
How to execute it well
Use Reddit's search function to find industry-specific subreddits, then check the member count (visible in the sidebar). Create a list of 10-20 subreddits in your target range. Prioritize communities where recent posts have 5-20 comments (indicating active engagement). Subscribe to these subreddits and monitor daily for questions matching your expertise. Avoid communities with under 500 members, they lack sufficient activity for sustainable growth. Track which subreddits in your list generate the most quality conversations. Focus deeper on 3-5 top-performing communities rather than spreading thin across 20. When you're mapping out where your audience spends time online, our market clarity reports identify the exact forums, subreddits, and communities where your target customers are most active and vocal.
6. You have to know that 150-500 karma threshold unlocks promotional freedom
What it is
Build your Reddit karma to 150-500+ through genuine participation before ever mentioning your brand or product. This threshold typically takes 2-4 weeks at 20 minutes daily, providing detailed answers in your expertise area without any self-promotion. Accounts below this threshold face immediate removal and shadowbanning when posting promotional content. Ken Savage from Launch Club AI states: "I've never been removed for anything above 500 karma."
Why it works
Reddit's spam filters and subreddit moderators use karma as a trust signal. New accounts (under 150 karma) get flagged automatically by AutoModerator in most valuable subreddits. Even if your content is genuinely helpful, low-karma accounts trigger suspicion. Higher karma grants you the benefit of doubt, moderators assume you're a community member first, marketer second. This is the difference between your post staying up or getting removed within minutes.
How to execute it well
Create your Reddit account and spend the first 2-4 weeks only answering questions in your expertise area. Don't mention your product at all. Sort target subreddits by "Rising" and provide thorough, detailed answers as if you were getting paid for it. Aim for 4-7 high-value comments per day. To accelerate karma building, find hot and controversial posts and write thoughtful (not inflammatory) comments that add perspective to debates, these generate upvotes faster. Once you hit 150 karma, you can start occasional brand mentions. At 500+ karma, you have significant freedom. Don't try to gain karma through self-promotion, it won't work and will flag your account. Track your karma daily in your profile.
7. You should use the "I made a site to [specific benefit]" title formula
What it is
Structure your post titles for r/InternetIsBeautiful and similar subreddits using the exact formula: "I made a site to [specific user benefit]." Test 10 title variations with 5 friends, wait 24 hours, then ask which they remember, use the most memorable one. Marc Lou used this formula to generate 47,000 visitors in 24 hours from r/InternetIsBeautiful and brought 100,000+ total visitors using Reddit tactics.
Why it works
This formula hits three psychological triggers simultaneously: (1) Authenticity ("I made") signals genuine creator sharing, not corporate marketing; (2) Immediate value ("to [benefit]") tells users exactly what they get; (3) Curiosity gap, they need to click to see how you delivered that benefit. The formula's simplicity makes it memorable, passing the 24-hour memory test. r/InternetIsBeautiful specifically rewards novel, useful web creations presented humbly.
How to execute it well
Start with your product's core benefit. Write 10 variations: "I made a site to turn any image into pixel art," "I made a site to generate color palettes from photos," "I made a site to automatically subtitle videos." Send all 10 to 5 friends via disappearing message if possible. After 24 hours, delete the message and ask: "Which headline do you remember from yesterday?" The most-remembered title has the strongest hook. Use that exact wording for your Reddit post. Keep titles under 80 characters for optimal upvotes. The benefit must be immediately clear and specific, avoid vague phrases like "improve productivity." Concrete benefits like "convert PDFs to editable text in 2 clicks" perform better. Don't include your product name in the title. Before you test any headlines, knowing what benefits your audience actually cares about is critical, which is exactly what our market clarity reports reveal through deep analysis of customer complaints and desires.
Sources: Marc Lou Newsletter, Indie Hackers8. You should post 5-6 hours before peak activity time, not during it
What it is
Track when your target subreddit has the most active users, then intentionally post 5-6 hours before that peak window. This counterintuitive timing allows your post to gain early momentum during the quiet period and ride the wave when traffic arrives. One founder grew their newsletter to 2,000+ subscribers at 70-100+ subscribers per week using this timing. Their most successful post generated 73,000 views and 800+ upvotes, bringing 73 subscribers in 1 day (105 in 48 hours).
Why it works
During peak times, the feed is dominated by posts that already have 100-1,000+ upvotes, capturing all attention. Your new post, no matter how valuable, gets buried under established viral content. By posting during silent hours, your content becomes one of the few fresh posts available. Early upvotes from the smaller active audience start accumulating. When peak traffic arrives hours later, Reddit's algorithm has already identified your post as gaining traction, pushing it higher in feeds. This creates a snowball effect.
How to execute it well
Use tools like Later for Reddit's "Top Post Analysis" to identify when top posts in your target subreddit were published historically. Note the peak activity hours. Calculate 5-6 hours before that time, this becomes your posting window. For example, if r/Entrepreneur peaks at 2 PM EST, post at 8-9 AM EST. Schedule posts in advance using Reddit's native scheduling or Buffer. Monitor the post's performance in the first 2 hours. This strategy works best for communities with clear geographic concentration (US-heavy subreddits have predictable Eastern Time peaks). Global communities may not have distinct peaks. Don't obsess over perfect timing, Reddit is global and posts can go viral at any time.
Sources: Indie Hackers, Indie Hackers9. You must convert blog posts into Reddit-native markdown format completely
What it is
Transform blog content into Reddit-native format by: (1) removing all photos, (2) removing all self-promotional links and CTAs, (3) rewriting in Reddit markdown, (4) changing the title to first-person perspective (making it seem like the entrepreneur themselves is posting, not you promoting them). Pat Walls used this tactic to get his first 10,000 email subscribers for Starter Story. Individual posts generated 20,000+ views and approximately 50 subscribers each.
Why it works
Redditors immediately spot and downvote content that looks like it was copy-pasted from a blog. External links signal traffic theft, you're pulling users away from Reddit. Native markdown formatting with zero images signals "I wrote this for Reddit" (even if you adapted it). First-person perspective creates authenticity, "$1.1M/month selling beer coolers [profit included]" feels like a founder sharing their journey, not a marketer promoting someone else's interview. Understanding what resonates means knowing what your audience actually wants to read, which is exactly what our market clarity reports help you figure out before you write a single word.
How to execute it well
Take your original blog post. Strip all images, replace with text descriptions if absolutely necessary ("Graph showing 300% growth in Q3"). Remove every hyperlink, especially to your site. Rewrite the headline in first-person: change "Interview: How this founder made $1.1M" to "$1.1M/month selling beer coolers [profit included]." Convert formatting to Reddit markdown: use **bold**, headers with ##, bullet points with *. Post the entire article in Reddit, not a snippet with a "read more" link. Add subtle product mention in your profile or a comment if needed. This requires significant effort, you're essentially rewriting content. Don't cut corners with partial conversions, Redditors will notice. Post to r/Entrepreneur, r/startups, and niche industry subreddits relevant to the story.
Sources: Starter Story, Growth in Reverse10. You should answer old ranking Reddit threads for SEO amplification
What it is
Google your target keywords to find which Reddit threads rank in top search results, then contribute valuable answers to those old, already-ranking threads even if they have many existing responses. This builds visibility both on Reddit and in Google search results. Kamel Ben Yacoub noticed his responses gaining traction on search result pages after Google's algorithm shift, calling it SEO amplification in a surprising way.
Why it works
Google's 2024 algorithm update massively prioritized forum content, especially Reddit. Threads ranking on page 1 of Google receive ongoing traffic for months or years, not just the day they were posted. By adding your expertise to these established threads, you gain dual visibility: (1) Redditors discovering the thread through search, (2) Google searchers reading the thread directly in results. Your comment becomes permanent searchable content. Counterintuitively, old threads with high Google ranking provide better ROI than new threads with Reddit-only visibility.
How to execute it well
Take your 10-20 primary keywords (problems your product solves). Google each one individually. Look for Reddit threads in the top 10 results, these are your targets. Click through and read the entire thread. Add a comprehensive answer that genuinely improves the discussion, don't just repeat existing responses. Include specific data, examples, or frameworks other answers lack. Mention your product naturally if relevant: "I built [tool] specifically to address this issue because [reason]." Track which threads you've contributed to and monitor your comment's upvotes over time. Focus on threads with 50-500 upvotes, these have enough traction to rank but aren't so viral that your answer gets buried. Prioritize threads from 3-12 months ago, they're old enough to have established ranking but recent enough that comments are still read.
11. You have to know that 60-80 character titles dramatically increase upvotes
What it is
Foundation Marketing analysis revealed that post titles with exactly 60-80 characters consistently earn more upvotes than shorter or longer alternatives. Combine this length with question formats for maximum engagement. Posts with external links (especially video links) earn the most upvotes according to Foundation Marketing's research, but title optimization matters regardless of content type.
Why it works
Titles under 60 characters often lack sufficient context to intrigue readers, they're too vague. Titles over 80 characters get truncated on mobile and appear overwrought. The 60-80 character sweet spot provides enough context to spark curiosity while remaining scannable. Questions engage psychological curiosity gaps, readers want to see the answers. Reddit's mobile-dominant user base (over 60% of traffic) particularly benefits from this length optimization since longer titles cut off in feeds.
How to execute it well
Draft your initial post title naturally, then check the character count (use an online character counter). If under 60 characters, add specific details or context: "How do you handle customer support?" becomes "How do you handle customer support for a SaaS with 10,000 users?" If over 80 characters, ruthlessly cut unnecessary words. Reframe as a question if possible: "I struggled with React state management until I learned this pattern" becomes "What React state management pattern changed how you build apps?" Test titles at exactly 67-72 characters (mid-range) first. Character count is measured including spaces and punctuation. Use specificity to add characters, numbers, timeframes, and industry terms make titles more compelling while hitting the length target. Don't artificially inflate length with filler words, every word should add value.
Sources: Sprout Social, Single Grain12. You must adapt content to each subreddit's specific sentiment and voice
What it is
Research what content previously trended successfully in your target subreddit with similar keywords, then craft headlines and tone specifically matching that community's sentiment. A single piece of content needs 5-10 different versions for different subreddits. One founder achieved 16,000+ signups by trending on Reddit 26 times in 4 months, crediting adaptation to each subreddit's voice as the critical success factor.
Why it works
Each subreddit develops its own culture, values, and communication style. r/recruitinghell rewards negative, complaining tones about hiring frustrations. r/Entrepreneur celebrates optimistic success stories. r/webdev prefers technical deep-dives with code examples. One-size-fits-all content gets ignored or removed. Adapting to each community's voice signals you're a member who understands local culture, not a drive-by marketer. Moderators approve content that feels right for their community.
How to execute it well
Before posting to a new subreddit, spend 30 minutes reading the top 20 posts from the past month. Note patterns: Are titles questions or statements? Do they use technical jargon or plain language? What tone dominates (sarcastic, earnest, angry, celebratory)? For each subreddit, create a voice profile document. When adapting your content, rewrite the title and opening paragraph to match. Example: Product Hunt post titled "We launched our AI tool" becomes "Launched an AI tool and got 500 upvotes, here's what worked" for r/Entrepreneur and "Built this ML model to automate X, looking for feedback on architecture" for r/MachineLearning. Don't just change the title, adjust the entire post's tone and structure. Some subreddits prefer short, punchy posts while others reward comprehensive deep-dives. Post links in comments rather than post bodies for subreddits that prefer discussion over promotion. Understanding what voice and positioning will resonate with each community becomes much easier when you know what your audience already responds to, which is why our market clarity reports analyze successful competitor messaging and audience sentiment across different channels.
Sources: Indie Hackers, Single Grain13. You should follow the 90/10 content distribution rule religiously
What it is
Make 90% of your Reddit activity genuinely non-promotional valuable contributions, while only 10% promotes your product or service. This means for every 100 posts and comments you make, only 10 should mention your company or include links to your site. HubSpot and Gleam both recommend this ratio as a practical implementation of Reddit's community standards.
Why it works
Reddit's spam filters and community culture aggressively punish accounts that exist primarily for self-promotion. The 90/10 rule (also called the 10:1 rule) keeps you below detection thresholds for both automated spam filters and moderator scrutiny. More importantly, it builds genuine trust capital. When 90% of your history shows helping others without agenda, the 10% promotional content is viewed as credible expertise-based recommendations rather than spam. This ratio mirrors Reddit's community values, contribute first, benefit second.
How to execute it well
Track your Reddit activity manually or with a spreadsheet. For every self-promotional post or comment you make (anything linking to your site, mentioning your product, or driving to your business), make 9 non-promotional contributions. These can include: answering questions in your expertise area with no product mention, sharing industry insights, discussing competitors' products objectively, helping with technical issues, or contributing to discussions in hobby subreddits unrelated to your business. Regularly audit your profile page to ensure the ratio holds from an outside observer's perspective. New accounts should follow an even stricter 95/5 ratio for the first 2-3 months until karma reaches 500+. Don't try to game this by posting low-effort filler comments just to hit the ratio, Redditors spot this immediately.
14. You should implement 4-7 high-value comments daily as SEO strategy
What it is
Make leaving 4-7 genuinely valuable comments per day your foundational Reddit strategy. This builds trust, karma, and long-term visibility through accumulated searchable content. Backlinko specifically recommends 4-7 as the optimal daily range based on analyzing successful Reddit marketers.
Why it works
Consistency compounds on Reddit. Four thoughtful comments daily equals 120+ expert contributions monthly, establishing you as a recognizable authority in target communities. Unlike posts (which require significant effort and face higher moderation), comments have lower barriers, you're responding to existing conversations rather than creating new ones. Each comment becomes permanent searchable content that Google now indexes and ranks, building your SEO footprint. This volume creates multiple entry points for discovery.
How to execute it well
Allocate 15-20 minutes per comment during your Reddit activity blocks. Aim for 300-500 word responses that thoroughly address the question with specific examples, data, or frameworks. Don't comment just to hit the number, only respond when you have genuine expertise to share. Use a simple tracking spreadsheet: Date, Subreddit, Topic, Link to Comment, Upvotes Received. Review monthly to identify which comment types generate the most engagement, then double down on those formats. Four comments is the minimum for building presence, seven is the maximum before quality drops. If you can't find 4-7 questions worth answering in your target communities, you're either in the wrong subreddits or need broader keyword monitoring. Focus on comments that age well, evergreen topics that remain searchable for months.
Sources: Backlinko, Single Grain15. You should use non-anonymous profiles with real identity strategically
What it is
In B2B contexts, use your real name, professional headshot, and brief company description in your Reddit profile, the opposite of typical Reddit anonymity. This builds immediate trust and brand awareness with decision-makers. Kamel Ben Yacoub used this strategy to close 2 clients and secure speaking opportunities, noting: "People want to work with a human, not a Reddit avatar."
Why it works
B2B buyers want to work with humans, not avatars. When a CMO at a $50M company sees a thoughtful answer from "RandomUser847," they move on. When they see the same answer from "Kamel Ben Yacoub, PPC Agency Founder" with a professional photo, they click through to learn more. Real identity signals confidence and accountability, you stand behind your advice publicly. This differentiation is powerful precisely because so few Redditors use real identities.
How to execute it well
Set your Reddit username to your real name if creating a new account (like u/JohnSmithMarketing). If using an existing account, add your real name to your profile description. Upload a professional headshot as your profile picture. Write a brief bio: "Founder of [Company]. [Industry] expert. Sharing what I've learned building [thing]." Add links to your LinkedIn and company website. Engage exactly as you would anonymously (helpful, genuine, non-salesy), but your identity makes every contribution a brand-building opportunity. This strategy works for B2B and professional contexts, it's less effective for B2C gaming, entertainment, or consumer products where anonymity is valued. Don't use real identity if your product operates in controversial spaces or if you might need plausible deniability later. Real identity creates accountability, you can't post aggressive, controversial, or inappropriate content without consequences.
Each of our market clarity reports includes a study of both positive and negative competitor reviews, helping uncover opportunities and gaps.
In our market clarity reports, you'll always find a sharp analysis of your competitors.
Our market clarity reports contain between 100 and 300 insights about your market.
Read more articles
- How to Get Traffic from Reddit: Feedback from 100+ People
- Getting Started On Reddit (Feedback from 100+ Users)
- How To Make a Popular Reddit Post (Feedback from 100+ Users)
- How To Warm Up a Reddit Account (Feedback from 100+ Users)
- How To Make a Popular Reddit Comment (Feedback from 100+ Users)
