Launching On Product Hunt (Feedback from 100+ Entrepreneurs)
Last updated: 16 October 2025
Get a full market clarity report so you can build a winning digital business
We research digital businesses every day, if you're building in this space, get our market clarity reports
We spent weeks digging through Reddit threads, Indie Hackers posts, Hacker News discussions, and founder communities to understand what actually works when launching on Product Hunt.
We compiled real feedback from founders who succeeded, analyzed what the ones who failed missed, and filtered out all the outdated advice.
If you want this kind of sharp, research-backed clarity before building your next product, check out our market clarity reports that do exactly this for 100+ product categories.
Quick Summary
Most Product Hunt launches fail because founders skip the 30-day prep window and don't understand how the algorithm actually weights votes.
Success comes from warming up supporter accounts weeks in advance, prioritizing comment engagement over raw upvotes, and maintaining steady vote velocity throughout the entire 24-hour period. The biggest non-obvious insight: one quality comment from an established user equals roughly three upvotes algorithmically, and votes from brand-new accounts get removed or heavily discounted by spam filters.
Treat Product Hunt as a PR event for validation and email capture, not a sustainable growth channel, because PH users have the worst retention rates of any acquisition source.
In our market clarity reports, for each product and market, we detect signals from across the web and forums, identify pain points, and measure their frequency and intensity so you can be sure you're building something your market truly needs.
20 Non-Obvious Tactics That Separate Successful Product Hunt Launches from Failed Ones
1. You must warm up supporter accounts 30 days before launch
What it is:
Contact your supporters 30+ days before launch and ask them to create Product Hunt accounts immediately, then engage with other products before your launch day.Why it works:
Product Hunt's algorithm heavily penalizes votes from newly created accounts. Brand-new accounts created on launch day will likely have their votes removed or significantly devalued, potentially causing shadow bans. The algorithm explicitly values engagement from seasoned members with established karma scores over fresh accounts. One upvote from an established high-karma user can equal 10+ upvotes from new users in terms of algorithmic weight.How to execute it well:
Start outreach exactly 30 days before your planned launch (not 29 days, not 2 weeks). Send a specific email asking people to create Product Hunt accounts NOW, emphasizing their votes won't count if they wait until launch day. Ask them to spend 5-10 minutes upvoting and commenting on 2-3 other products they genuinely like. Follow up 3 days later with a reminder to engage with PH again. Keep a spreadsheet tracking who has created accounts and their PH karma level. Focus on getting Notable badge users or those with 5+ karma points.2. You have to know one comment equals three upvotes algorithmically
What it is:
Product Hunt's ranking algorithm weights one quality comment as approximately equal to 3 upvotes, making comment engagement significantly more valuable than silent upvotes.Why it works:
The algorithm heavily values engagement metrics, not just raw vote counts. Quality comments from active users signal genuine interest and product-market fit to Product Hunt's system, boosting ranking more than silent upvotes. This means a product with 300 upvotes and 100 comments can rank higher than a product with 400 upvotes and 30 comments. Comments also function like Amazon reviews (they dramatically increase the click-through rate from the Product Hunt homepage to your website because users read them to decide if they should try your product).How to execute it well:
In ALL your outreach, explicitly ask people to leave detailed feedback or comments, not just upvote. Phrase it as "would love your feedback and thoughts in the comments" rather than "please upvote." Reach out to former users and power users specifically requesting they write 2-3 sentence reviews explaining what they love. Guide them toward specificity: "this solved X problem by doing Y" rather than generic "great tool." Respond to every single comment within 2 hours (ideally within 10 minutes for the first 4 hours). Have 2-3 team members ready to answer questions from different angles. Ask follow-up questions in your replies to encourage deeper discussions.3. You should target makers who recently launched within 30 days
What it is:
In the weeks before your launch, actively support other Product Hunt launches (especially those from the past month) with meaningful comments and upvotes, then reach out to those makers personally for reciprocal support.Why it works:
Makers who recently launched have dramatically better response rates than those who launched 2+ years ago because the experience is fresh and they understand the effort involved. They're also still active in the PH community and are primed to reciprocate support. This builds authentic social capital rather than transactional vote exchanges. Additionally, their recent activity means they have higher karma scores that carry more algorithmic weight.How to execute it well:
Browse Product Hunt daily for 2-4 weeks before your launch. Filter for products launched in the past 30 days in your category or adjacent categories. Leave thoughtful, substantive comments (not just "great product"), minimum 2-3 sentences explaining what you like or asking specific questions. Upvote 5-10 products per week that you genuinely find interesting. Save the makers' profiles and note their engagement level. Message them 1-2 weeks before your launch: "I loved [specific thing about their product]. I'm launching [your product] on [date] and would appreciate your support and feedback." Track responses in a spreadsheet to identify your most engaged supporters.4. You have to know Coming Soon subscribers become automatic voters
What it is:
Create and heavily promote a Product Hunt Coming Soon teaser page at least 2-4 weeks before launch. Users who click "Notify me" receive notifications on launch day and become guaranteed early supporters.Why it works:
When Product Hunt features your product (not all get featured), everyone who subscribed to your teaser page receives an automatic email notification at launch. This typically results in 200-300 guaranteed upvotes if you have 500 teaser followers, a massive early momentum advantage. Multiple founders reported that their Coming Soon subscribers literally saved launches that were hidden from the homepage for hours by providing enough votes to stay alive until they got featured.How to execute it well:
Create your teaser page minimum 2 weeks out (4 weeks is significantly better). Include compelling copy, a strong tagline, and at least one preview image. Share the teaser link across ALL channels: LinkedIn, Twitter, email signatures, website header, blog posts, community forums. Post in relevant Slack groups, Facebook communities, and subreddits (frame as "getting early feedback"). Track teaser page subscribers (these are your guaranteed day-1 supporters). Update your teaser page with small content improvements to keep it fresh. Use the teaser link in your email signature starting 2 weeks out for passive growth.5. You must manually change launch status even after scheduling
What it is:
Even after scheduling your launch time in Product Hunt's system, you MUST manually toggle the launch status from pre-launch to live at 12:01 AM PT, or your product won't be featured.Why it works (or rather, why NOT doing this fails):
Product Hunt's system requires manual activation despite having a scheduling feature. Products that remain in pre-launch status miss ALL organic Product Hunt traffic and homepage visibility (you're essentially launching into a void). Multiple founders reported scheduling their launch, going to sleep, and waking up to discover they had zero organic traffic because the product never went live.How to execute it well:
Set your launch time to 12:01 AM PT in the Product Hunt submission form. Set an alarm for 12:00 AM PT on launch day (or have a team member in a compatible timezone). At 12:01 AM PT, go to your product page on Product Hunt. Manually toggle the status from Scheduled or Pre-launch to Live. Verify within 5 minutes that your product appears on the Product Hunt homepage. If it doesn't appear, immediately contact hello@producthunt.com via the Intercom widget. Have a backup person (team member or friend) who can do this if you can't be awake at midnight.Sources: Indie Hackers, Indie Hackers6. You must segment outreach into three time zone waves minimum
What it is:
Plan at least three distinct outreach pushes throughout launch day coordinated across global time zones: 12:01 AM PT (launch), 7-9 AM PT (US wakes up), and 2-4 PM PT (afternoon momentum).Why it works:
Product Hunt's algorithm explicitly favors steady engagement velocity throughout the 24-hour period over one-time spikes. Distributing votes naturally prevents spam flags and maintains consistent ranking momentum. Sudden vote surges from one geographic location trigger the algorithm's gaming detection and can lead to vote removal or shadow bans. Founders who coordinated global supporters saw 3-5x better results than those who sent one mass email.How to execute it well:
Segment your email list and contact list by time zone or geography (Asia/Australia, Europe, US East Coast, US West Coast). Create a detailed schedule: 12:01 AM PT contact India/Asia supporters (their working hours: 1-3 PM IST), 7-9 AM PT first US push as East Coast wakes up, 10 AM-12 PM PT Europe midday push (6-8 PM GMT), 2-4 PM PT second US push for afternoon momentum, 6-8 PM PT Asia second wave (next day morning for them). Use email scheduling tools to automate these batches. Coordinate with supporters in different time zones ahead of time. Track supporter contacts by continent in a spreadsheet. Space outreach so you get roughly 25-50 votes per hour (steady rate).7. You should send personal DMs not mass posts for conversion
What it is:
Send individual, personalized direct messages to supporters rather than mass posting to Reddit, Slack groups, or social media. One-on-one DMs to your network drive 10x more conversions than organic social posts.Why it works:
Personal relationships and direct asks trump algorithms and public broadcasts. People are significantly more likely to support someone who messages them directly versus seeing a generic post in a crowded feed. The personal connection creates reciprocity and makes them feel valued as an individual supporter rather than part of a mass audience. Multiple founders compared results: tweets with 10,000+ views generated minimal upvotes, while 40-50 personal DMs generated 30-40 conversions.How to execute it well:
Create a comprehensive list of everyone in your professional network (former colleagues, industry contacts, founders you've helped, friends). Write personalized messages (not templates), reference your relationship: "hey [name], we worked together at [company] and I'd love your eyes on what I've been building." Be specific about what you need: "would love your support and feedback on Product Hunt today" (don't say "upvote"). Use the "like this post and I'll DM you a reminder" strategy on Twitter to build an opted-in list of 40-100 people. DM supporters across platforms: LinkedIn InMail, Twitter DMs, WhatsApp, Slack, email (wherever your relationship is strongest). Send calendar invites to confirmed supporters so they don't forget. Wake up early to personally message people in different time zones.8. You must avoid launch parties with same-location voting completely
What it is:
Never gather your team, supporters, or friends in one physical location to vote simultaneously, and ensure team members vote from different locations and times.Why it works (or rather, why NOT doing this fails):
Multiple upvotes from the same IP address or physical location trigger Product Hunt's spam filters immediately, leading to vote removal and potential shadow bans. The algorithm is specifically designed to detect and penalize coordinated voting from the same network. This can completely tank your launch (votes get removed, your ranking drops, and you may get flagged permanently).How to execute it well:
Explicitly tell ALL supporters NOT to gather for launch parties or voting events. If your team is in the same office, have people vote at different times (space by 2-3 hours). Better: have team members vote from home, coffee shops, or mobile networks (not office WiFi). Communicate this in advance: "important, please vote from your personal device and location, not from our office or any group event." Don't organize vote together Zoom calls where everyone clicks at the same moment. Spread votes throughout the 24-hour period from various time zones and networks. If supporters are in the same city, ask them to vote at different times of day.9. You have to know hunter follower count stopped mattering
What it is:
In the past, having a hunter with a massive following (10,000+ followers) was critical because their followers received email notifications. Product Hunt stopped sending these notifications, making follower count nearly irrelevant.Why it works:
Product Hunt changed its notification system so hunters' followers no longer get automatic emails about new hunts. This means a hunter with 38,000 followers provides no more distribution advantage than self-hunting. However, respected hunters in your niche still provide value through their personal engagement in comments (which signals quality), their karma score (affects algorithmic weight), and their genuine interest (can lead to strategic feedback that improves your positioning).How to execute it well:
Don't stress if you can't get a big name hunter (the impact is significantly less than before 2023). If working with a hunter, choose based on RELEVANCE to your category, not follower count. Look for hunters who've successfully launched products in your specific niche (design tools, no-code, dev tools). Self-hunting is now completely viable and accepted by Product Hunt. If you do get a hunter, use them for strategic advice and genuine feedback, not just their name. Focus energy on your own community building rather than hunter hunting. Research: look at successful products in your category and see if they used hunters or self-hunted.10. You should choose launch day based on your goal first
What it is:
Strategic day selection based on your primary objective rather than following generic "Tuesday-Thursday is best" advice. Different days optimize for different outcomes: weekends for #1 badge, mid-week for traffic, Monday or Friday for balance.Why it works:
Launch day determines both competition level and traffic potential. Weekend launches have 60-70% less competition (need around 500-600 votes for #1) but also lower traffic. Weekday launches (Tuesday through Thursday) have 5-10x more active users but require 700-1,000+ votes for top spots. The best day depends entirely on whether your goal is ranking or social proof versus maximum traffic or exposure.How to execute it well:
Define your primary goal: if it's #1 badge for social proof or credibility, choose Saturday or Sunday; if it's moderate ranking plus good engagement, choose Monday or Friday; if it's maximum traffic regardless of ranking, choose Tuesday-Thursday. Consider your audience: if targeting developers with side projects, weekends work better (they experiment on weekends). Assess your network size: small network (less than 500 supporters) means weekend is strategic, large network (1,000+) means weekday is feasible. Check historical data: use hunted.space to see typical vote counts by day. Once you go live at 12:01 AM, you're locked in (choose carefully). Solo founders typically do better on weekends, teams with large networks do better mid-week.11. You should use simple Loom walkthrough over expensive video production
What it is:
A straightforward 3-5 minute Loom screen recording of you walking through the product outperforms polished, professionally produced $10,000 videos.Why it works:
The Product Hunt community values authenticity over production quality. A genuine, relatable walkthrough feels trustworthy and shows the real product experience. Professional marketing videos can feel sterile and disconnected from the maker story that PH users love. Multiple founders spent 4+ weeks and $10,000 on professional videos (storyboards, audio engineers, animations) only to see simple Loom demos perform just as well or better.How to execute it well:
Open Loom and start a screen recording. Talk naturally while showing the product (imagine explaining it to a friend). Structure: show the problem (15 seconds), show your solution (2-3 minutes), show key features or benefits (1-2 minutes). Be conversational, not scripted (authenticity matters more than polish). Keep it 3-5 minutes maximum (attention spans are short). Ensure good audio quality (use a decent mic if possible, but laptop mic is acceptable). Upload to YouTube (must be public, not unlisted) before launch day.12. You must show the UI and caption screenshots directly
What it is:
Embed text captions directly within your product screenshot images explaining what each screen does, and focus on showing the actual user interface rather than marketing imagery.Why it works:
Product Hunt users want to SEE what your product looks like, not read abstract marketing copy. Captions within images ensure viewers understand your product even if they just quickly scan images without reading descriptions. The PH CEO explicitly stated: "to be even more explicit, show the UI. The PH community wants to know what your product looks like." Users make quick decisions based on visual scanning (embedded captions catch attention while separate descriptions often get skipped).How to execute it well:
Create minimum 3 gallery images (4-6 is optimal). Use high-quality screenshots of your actual product interface. Add text overlays or captions directly on the images using Figma, Canva, or Photoshop. Caption format: brief headline (6-8 words) explaining the feature or benefit shown. Show different aspects: main interface, key features, user workflows, results dashboard. Avoid abstract marketing imagery or conceptual graphics. Ensure first frame of any GIF is compelling (GIFs don't autoplay, only animate on hover).13. You must craft tagline with action verb and clear value
What it is:
Your tagline must include an action verb and articulate a clear, specific value proposition in under 60 characters. Avoid vague "platform to turbocharge" language.Why it works:
The tagline is arguably the most important marketing asset you'll create (it's the main CTA that determines whether users click from the Product Hunt homepage to your product page). Clarity combined with an action verb creates both understanding and curiosity. Vague or overly grand taglines sacrifice clarity, causing users to skip your product. Product Hunt's CEO explicitly warned: "a common failure mode is trying to make a tagline seem grander but in the process losing clarity."How to execute it well:
Start with action verbs: make, build, launch, find, turn, create, ship. Include specific, quantifiable benefits when possible. Keep it under 60 characters total. Test format: [action verb] + [what] + [specific benefit]. Examples of great taglines: "make Chrome faster and use 10x less memory", "turn Figma files into full-stack apps in minutes", "launch your own swag store in 3 easy steps." Bad examples to avoid: "an AI platform to turbocharge productivity" (vague, no action), "the future of work" (meaningless buzzwords). Test your tagline on people unfamiliar with your product (if they can't explain what you do after reading it, rewrite).14. You should prioritize email capture over upvote count completely
What it is:
Set email capture (target: 1,000+ emails) as your primary success metric instead of Product of the Day ranking or upvote count. Structure your launch to optimize for conversions, not vanity metrics.Why it works:
Upvotes and rankings are vanity metrics that fade after 24 hours. Your email list provides sustained conversion opportunities and validates product-market fit long-term. This is where real, at-scale conversion happens according to launch experts. Product Hunt gives you a traffic spike (2,000-10,000 visitors for top products), but if you don't capture emails, you lose that audience forever. When building a product that solves a real market need, insights from research-backed market reports combined with strong email capture turn temporary visibility into lasting customer relationships.How to execute it well:
BEFORE launch day, add a prominent email capture CTA on your landing page. Optimize landing page specifically for PH visitors: clear headline matching your PH tagline, strong value proposition above the fold, email capture form immediately visible (not below the fold), remove friction (minimize required fields). Offer an enticing incentive: free trial extended (7 to 14 days), exclusive template or guide, early access to features. Set up email nurture campaign BEFORE launch so new signups get immediate value. Track email signups as primary KPI in your dashboard, not just ranking. Set goal: B2B equals 200-500 emails, B2C equals 1,000-2,000 emails. Use Product Hunt-specific tracking (UTM parameters) to segment this cohort.15. You have to know vote quality beats quantity significantly
What it is:
Product Hunt's algorithm weights upvotes from established, high-karma users (especially Gold and Silver badge holders) significantly more than votes from regular or new users. One upvote from a Notable user can equal 10+ regular upvotes.Why it works:
The algorithm uses karma scores as a proxy for authenticity and community standing. This prevents gaming the system with fake accounts or paid votes. Real example: a product with 300 upvotes from high-weight supporters ranked HIGHER than a competitor with 400 upvotes from average users. After end-of-day recalibration (when PH removes suspected bot votes and new accounts), rankings can shift dramatically based on vote quality rather than quantity.How to execute it well:
Identify high-karma users before launch: look for Notable badges (gold or silver indicators), check user profiles for 5+ karma points minimum, find active community members who regularly comment. Target users who've engaged with similar products in your category. Research makers or hunters with strong Product Hunt presence. Personalize outreach to these high-value users (they get hundreds of launch requests). Focus on building genuine relationships with 20-30 high-karma users rather than mass outreach to 500 random people. Track which supporters have gold or silver badges in your spreadsheet. Prioritize response time to comments from these users.16. You should report spam accounts with red balloons immediately
What it is:
If you notice an influx of comments from brand-new users (indicated by a red balloon icon next to their names), use Product Hunt's reporting function to mark them as spam.Why it works:
Competitors can deploy bots with new accounts to trigger Product Hunt's spam filters against YOUR product. If the algorithm sees your launch attracting primarily new accounts, it may flag your entire launch as suspicious, leading to vote removal and deranking. By proactively reporting these accounts, you help Product Hunt identify malicious activity and protect your launch's integrity.How to execute it well:
Monitor comments throughout launch day for red balloon icons (indicates accounts created within last around 30 days). If you see suspicious patterns (multiple new accounts commenting within minutes, generic comments like "interesting" or "nice work", non-relevant comments), take action. Click the three dots on the suspicious comment. Select Report and choose reason: Spam or Suspicious Activity. If you see a coordinated bot attack (5+ new accounts in quick succession), contact Product Hunt support immediately via Intercom. Document the suspicious activity with screenshots. Don't report legitimate new users just to reduce competition (only report suspicious patterns).Sources: Lenny's Newsletter, Multi17. You must verify homepage featuring within 10 minutes exactly
What it is:
Immediately after launching at 12:01 AM PT, verify within 5-10 minutes that your product actually appears on the Product Hunt homepage. Products can have votes but not be featured, resulting in zero organic traffic.Why it works (or rather, why NOT doing this fails):
Only 30-40% of products get featured on the homepage. If you're not featured, you're in the Newest category (a death trap that receives virtually no organic traffic). Multiple founders reported launching, seeing upvotes from their network, assuming everything was fine, only to discover 6+ hours later they weren't on the homepage and had missed massive organic traffic opportunities.How to execute it well:
At 12:01 AM PT, submit or activate your launch. Within 5 minutes, open an incognito browser window. Go to producthunt.com homepage. Scroll through ALL products for that day (don't just check top 5). Search for your product name if you don't see it immediately. If you DON'T see your product after 10 minutes, take immediate action: open Intercom chat (bottom right of PH), contact hello@producthunt.com, tweet at @ProductHunt explaining the issue, be polite but urgent. Have a team member in a different location verify as well (different IP or browser).18. You should maintain 25 to 50 votes per hour consistently
What it is:
Monitor your upvote velocity throughout launch day and maintain a consistent rate of 25-50 votes per hour rather than getting all votes in sudden bursts.Why it works:
Product Hunt's algorithm monitors voting patterns in the first 4 hours to detect gaming. Rapid or unnatural spikes (100+ votes in 30 minutes followed by silence) trigger spam detection, leading to flagged or discounted votes and potential shadow bans. The algorithm favors steady engagement throughout the 24-hour period as a signal of genuine organic interest.How to execute it well:
Use hunted.space or similar tools to track real-time vote velocity (Product Hunt hides counts first 4 hours). Set hourly vote targets based on your goal: for top 3 need around 40-60 votes per hour average, for top 10 need around 20-30 votes per hour average. If vote rate is too slow (under 20 per hour), immediately ramp up outreach across social media, email batches, personal DMs. If vote rate is too fast (over 70 per hour), PAUSE outreach temporarily to avoid triggering spam flags, space out remaining contacts. Schedule outreach batches throughout the day, not all at once at midnight. Track hourly performance in a spreadsheet. Maintain momentum even during dead hours (3-6 AM PT, 10 PM to midnight PT).19. You should check competition and reschedule if necessary late
What it is:
Even after creating your teaser page and scheduling a date, monitor the Product Hunt homepage 1-2 days before your launch to assess competition. If major products or news events will overshadow yours, reschedule immediately.Why it works:
You can only relaunch on Product Hunt every 6 months, so picking the right day dramatically impacts long-term success. Launching the same day as a ChatGPT update, major brand launch, or during big tech news events can completely bury your product. Since you can reschedule up until launch, this gives you flexibility to optimize timing. Some products with 300-400 upvotes ranked higher than competitors with 500+ simply because they picked better launch days.How to execute it well:
Starting 3 days before launch, check Product Hunt's Coming Soon section daily. Look at the total number of products scheduled in your category for your chosen day. Check tech news sites (TechCrunch, The Verge) for major announcements scheduled that day. Use Twitter to monitor if major companies are teasing big launches. If you spot heavy competition or major news events, reschedule immediately (you can do this up to a few hours before). Consider switching to a weekend if weekday competition is fierce (trade traffic for better ranking). Recheck 12 hours before launch as a final verification.Sources: Indie Hackers, Lenny's Newsletter20. You have to know Product Hunt cohorts have worst retention
What it is:
Users acquired from Product Hunt launches typically have the worst retention rates of any acquisition channel, despite high initial traffic and excitement.Why it works (or rather, why it's important to understand):
Product Hunt users are tire-kickers (early adopters who love trying new products but rarely become long-term users). They're fundamentally different from users who discover you through search intent or word-of-mouth. Multiple experienced founders and PMs warned that naive startups get pulled into building entire product strategies around PH success, only to discover the PH signup cohort churns at 2-3x the rate of other sources. This is exactly why understanding real market signals matters more than chasing vanity metrics from any single launch platform.How to execute it well:
Segment Product Hunt users separately in your analytics from day one. Track these specific metrics by cohort: day 1, 7, 30, 90 retention rates, feature usage depth, conversion to paid (if freemium), engagement frequency. Set expectations BEFORE launch: PH is validation and awareness, not growth strategy; goal equals feedback and early traction, not sustainable user base; 5-15% of PH signups becoming active users is normal (versus 30-40% for other channels). Don't over-invest in features specifically for PH launch. Focus energy post-launch on converting the 10-15% who DO show engagement, not the 85% who don't. Use PH primarily for market validation and feedback, SEO backlinks, social proof (#1 badge, testimonials), early PR and investor attention (not sustainable growth or building core user base). Treat PH like a PR event, not a growth hack.
Each of our market clarity reports includes a study of both positive and negative competitor reviews, helping uncover opportunities and gaps.
In our market clarity reports, you'll always find a sharp analysis of your competitors.
We have market clarity reports for more than 100 products — find yours now.
Read more articles
